You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. Please enable scripts and reload this page.
An Official
Pennsylvania
Government Website
Translate
DEP
Department of Environmental Protection
About DEP
About DEP
Accessibility & Discrimination
Office of the Secretary
Testimony and Letters
Executive Staff
Office Locations
Regional Resources
Organization Chart
Awards
Job Opportunities
Office of Chief Counsel
Residents
Residents
Environmental Complaints
Flooding and Storm-Related Inf
My Air
My Water
Climate Change
Recycling and Waste Reduction
Litter
Mine Subsidence Insurance
Grants, Loans and Rebates
Environmental Education
Businesses
Businesses
Air
Land
Water
Energy
Radiation Protection
Program Integration
Infrastructure Act
Construction Contracts
Small Businesses
RISE PA
Public Participation
Public Participation
Environmental Quality Board
Citizens Advisory Council
Environmental Justice
Advisory Committees
Virtual Public Hearings
eComment
eNotice
Calendar of Events
Regulatory and Non-Regulatory
Data and Tools
Data and Tools
Electronic Submissions
eFACTS
GIS
Reports
Tools
DEP GreenPort
eLibrary
e-permitting Release Notes
Site Map
Webinars
Search
Search
Menu
Department of Environmental Protection
Menu
About DEP
About DEP
Accessibility & Discrimination
Office of the Secretary
Testimony and Letters
Executive Staff
Office Locations
Regional Resources
Organization Chart
Awards
Job Opportunities
Office of Chief Counsel
Residents
Residents
Environmental Complaints
Flooding and Storm-Related Inf
My Air
My Water
Climate Change
Recycling and Waste Reduction
Litter
Mine Subsidence Insurance
Grants, Loans and Rebates
Environmental Education
Businesses
Businesses
Air
Land
Water
Energy
Radiation Protection
Program Integration
Infrastructure Act
Construction Contracts
Small Businesses
RISE PA
Public Participation
Public Participation
Environmental Quality Board
Citizens Advisory Council
Environmental Justice
Advisory Committees
Virtual Public Hearings
eComment
eNotice
Calendar of Events
Regulatory and Non-Regulatory
Data and Tools
Data and Tools
Electronic Submissions
eFACTS
GIS
Reports
Tools
DEP GreenPort
eLibrary
e-permitting Release Notes
Site Map
Webinars
Report an Emergency
Environmental Complaints
Electronic Submissions
Regional Resources and Contacts
Newsroom
Grants
Reports
Public Records
DEP
>
Businesses
>
Program Integration
>
Pennsylvania Pipeline Portal
>
Comment Response Document Appendix
Begin Main Content Area
Page Content
Atlantic Sunrise Pipeline Comment Response Document- Appendix – Part 3
Comment letters and attachments received during the 1st Comment Period
Commentator 1
https://www.fractracker.org/a5ej20sjfwe/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/ASP_NHA_CPLN.pdf
https://www.fractracker.org/a5ej20sjfwe/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/ASP_NHA_Columbia_Northumberland.pdf
https://www.fractracker.org/a5ej20sjfwe/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/ASP_NHA_Schuylkill_Lebanon.pdf
https://www.fractracker.org/a5ej20sjfwe/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/ASP_NHA_Lebanon_Lancaster.pdf
Commentator 390, 403
Marion Menapace
Marion Menapce - 2
Commentator 404
The Accokeek, Mattawoman, Piscataway Creeks Communities Council – 08-01-16 - NCR
The Accokeek, Mattawoman, Piscataway Creeks Communities Council 08-01-16 – SCR
Commentator 406 – 1295
PA Signers PADEP Letter Final 08-16-16
Commentator 1296
Seneca Resources – 07-18-16
Commentator 1297 - 1310, 1313, 1314
Public Interest Groups Letter – 6-30-16
Jeffrey Lapp, EPA letter to FERC 6-27-16
Commentator 1300, 1313
Allegheny Defense Project 6-13-16
Table 1: DEP Water-Related Permits/Requests for Atlantic Sunrise Project.
Figure 1: Unconventional Shale Gas Wells Drilled in Pennsylvania (2004 – June 30, 2015)
Figure 2: Total Confirmed Bobcat Observations, 2006-2011
Figure 3: Seneca Resources' Leases on State Forest Lands
Figure 4: Pine Creek Gorge in Tioga County, Pennsylvania
Tennessee Aquatic Resources Report – Susquehanna River Project – March 2015
Commentator 1299, 1300, 1301, 1306, 1307, 1312 – 1314
Allegheny Defense Project, Appalachian Mountain Advocates, Clean Air Council, Lower Susquehanna Riverkeeper, Sierra Club letter – 5-31-16
Table 1: DEP Water-Related Permits/Requests for Atlantic Sunrise Project.
Figure 1: Unconventional Shale Gas Wells Drilled in Pennsylvania (2004 – June 30, 2015)
Figure 2: Total Confirmed Bobcat Observations, 2006-2011
Figure 3: Seneca Resources' Leases on State Forest Lands
Figure 4: Pine Creek Gorge in Tioga County, Pennsylvania
Tennessee Aquatic Resources Report – Susquehanna River Project – March 2015
DEP Wells Drilled by County 05-30-16
Tiadaghton 2005
Tiadaghton 2014
Forest Fragmentation
Seneca Tract 007
UR Tract 1040 Pine Creek
Commentator 1302
Lebanon Pipeline Awareness 05-30-16
Commentator 1302, 1480, 1485, 1601
Lebanon Pipeline Awareness
Commentator 1311
Russell S. Donnelly 07-30-16
Commentator 1312
Clean Air Council 05-31-16
Clean Air Council – Attachment
Commentator 1299 – 1309, 1312 - 1314, 1495
Allegheny Defense Project, Appalachian Mountain Advocates, Chesapeake Climate Action Network, Clean Air Council, Concerned Citizens of Lebanon County, Lancaster Against Pipelines, Lebanon Pipeline Awareness, Lower Susquehanna Riverkeeper, and Sierra Club 8-1-16
Commentator 1480
Megan Detter – 08-01-16
Commentator 1481
Veronica Klesh 05-17-16
Commentator 1482
S. R. Walker 7-25-16
Commentator 1483
DRN – 105 Permit Application 08-01-16
DRN – 105 Permit Application 05-30-16
DRN – WQ 401 Cert. Comment 07-20-15
DRN 2014 Field Observations of Tennessee Gas Pipeline Comments
Docket #PF14-8 - 08-16-14
Docket #PF14-5 - 03-25-15
DRN – Docket #P14-5 with attachments 03-25-16
Review of PennEast Pipeline Project Economic Impact Analysis 04-04-16
PADEP Comments to FERC 07-27-16
Economic Costs of the Atlantic Coast Pipeline 02-16
EPA Letter to FERC 06-27-16
The Effects of the Proposed PennEast Pipeline on Exceptional Value Wetlands in PA
Risks Associated with Natural Gas Pipeline Expansion in Appalachia
PennEast Pipeline Comp. Docket #PF15-1-000: Expert Report 08-10-16
Commentator 1484
Achieving Higher Quality Restoration Along Pipeline Rights-of-Way
The Effects of Converting Forest of Scrub Wetlands to Herbaceous Wetlands in PA
Docket #PF14-8 – Leidy Transco Line and Atlantic Sunrise Project Interconnected
Commentator 1485 – 1486
Quittapahilla Watershed Association 05-31-16
Quittapahilla Watershed Association 07-31-16
Commentator 1487
PA Senator Mike Folmer
Commentator 1491
Jane Popko 05-31-2016
Commentator 1492
Julie Brown 07-26-16
Commentator 1493
Curtin and Heefner - 05-24-16
Curtin and Heefner – 05-27-06
Curtin and Heefner – 05-31-16
Curtin and Heefner 8-1-16
Professional Review & Comment on Surface Water Impacts on the Nesbitt Property 8-1-16
Icarus Ecological Services - 7-29-16
FERC Transcontinental Gas Pipeline – Atlantic Sunrise Pipeline
Commentator 1540
Juliet Perrin – 05-24-16
Commentator 1541
Appalachian Mountain Club 05-31-16
Commentator 1543
Robin and Walter Kochan
Commentator 1544
Joan Byron
Commentator 1688
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/09/150915135827.htm
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/feb/05/fracking-water-america-drought-oil-gas
https://fracfocus.org/chemical-use/what-chemicals-are-used
http://www.gaslandthemovie.com/whats-fracking/faq/fracking-fluid
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/03/28/nebraska-fracking-fluid-would-you-drink-it-video_n_6961976.html
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/dec/14/fracking-hell-live-next-shale-gas-well-texas-us
http://www.alternet.org/environment/8-dangerous-side-effects-fracking-industry-doesnt-want-you-hear-about
http://www.biologicaldiversity.org/campaigns/americas_dangerous_pipelines/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_pipeline_accidents_in_the_United_States_in_the_21st_century
http://www.phmsa.dot.gov/pipeline/library/data-stats/pipelineincidenttrends
http://www.stuarthsmith.com/keystone-spill-is-more-proof-that-pipelines-are-unsafe-at-any-speed/
Commentator 1698
PennFuture 08-01-16
Commentator 1690 – 1692
Commissioners of Columbia County 6-3-16
Commentator 1693 – 1701
Members of the Fishing Creek Watershed Association 7-11-16
Commentator 1698, 1701 - 1704 and 4 nonlegible signatures
Columbia-Montour Coalition for Source Water Protection 7-25-16
Commentator 1705
Sheila Lunger 5-27-16
Commentator 1700 – 1701
John and Linda Dietrichson 5-26-16
Commentator 1706
Connie Giger
Comment letters and attachments received during the 2nd Comment Period
Commentator 4
Cindy Hose / Douglas Gross
Commentator 5
Craig Lehman – FERC Comments Final 06-14-16
Craig Lehman – FERC Hearing Comments FINAL 08-04-14
Commentator 9
Christopher D. McCue - Atlantic Sunrise FERC Hearing - 6-13-17
Commentator 10
Jennifer Wentzel
Commentator 15
Diane Ward
Commentator 16
Jerry George
Commentator 17
Kevin Lynn
Commentator 18
Thomas Barnard
Commentator 20
Peter Butler
Commentator 21
Ed Coker
Commentator 23
William Lochstet
William Lochstet - PA Interfaith Power and Light - Policy on Fossil Fuel Infrastructure
Commentator 26
Rebecca Peterson
Commentator 27
Tom Schachner
Commentator 28
Sandy Spencer
Commentator 29
Jim Spak
Commentator 30
Doug McLinko
Commentator 37
Paul Casparro
Commentator 38
Kelly Finan
Commentator 39
Mimi Shapiro and Paul Engleheart
Commentator 40
Susan Pantalone
Commentator 41
Larson Design Group 5-25-17
Commentator 43
Thomas Shepstone
Commentator 44
Dennis Wydra
Commentator 45
Fred Gaffney
Commentator 46
Sierra Shamer
Commentator 46, 118, 210, 213, 223, 225, 229, 247, 289, 2503 - 2536
40 Organizations
Commentator 47
Wayne Poncheri
Commentator 48
Rob McQuay
Commentator 51
John Walker
Commentator 52
Dean Marshall
Commentator 55
Tom Jamieson
Commentator 57
Jason Fink
Commentator 58
Linda Dietrichson
Commentator 60
Bob Garrett
Commentator 62
Ed Hill, Jr.
Commentator 118
Tim Spiese
Commentator 209
Jeff Logan
Commentator 210
Ann Pinca
Ann Pinca exhibit
Commentator 210, 223, 247, 270, 289, 2510, 2514, 2539 - 2543
8 Organizations
8 Organizations – exhibit 1
8 Organizations – exhibit 2
8 Organization - Seneca Resources' Leases on State Forest Lands
Commentator 211
Bill Eavenson – exhibit 1
Bill Eavenson – exhibit 2
Commentator 212
David Butterworth
Commentator 213
Faith Zerbe – exhibit 1
Faith Zerbe – exhibit 2
Commentator 213, 2537, 2538
Schmid Expert Technical Report
Commentator 214
Stephanie Wissman
Commentator 216
Steven Heckman
Commentator 217
Thomas Au
Commentator 218
Rudy Schmehl
Commentator 220
Jane Popko
Commentator 221
Jo Ellen Litz
Jo Ellen Litz exhibit
Commentator 223
Pamela Bishop
Commentator 225
Michael Schroeder
Commentator 229
Lea Zerbe
Commentator 242
PA Chamber of Business and Industry
Economic Impacts of the Atlantic Sunrise Pipeline Project
Commentator 243
Nancy Jeffries
Commentator 244
Lynda Like
Commentator 245
Jay Parrish
Commentator 246
Sally Wilson
Commentator 247
Malinda Clatterbuck
Commentator 248
Chelsea Nastka
Chelsea Nastka - exhibit
Commentator 249
Brian Earley
Commentator 250
Julie Garcia / Chief Karaya Guaili
Commentator 251
Robin McGuire
Commentator 255
Wade Pilgreen
Commentator 255, 342 - 954
Pipeliners Local 798
Commentator 256
Reverend Douglas Hunt
Commentator 257
Ryan Helms
Commentator 258
David N. Taylor
Commentator 259
Kevin Shivers
Commentator 260
Ed Braukus
Commentator 262
Jacob Hyder
Commentator 263
Toby Mack
Commentator 264
Mark Clatterbuck
Commentator 265
Mark Podlesny
Commentator 266
Roy WhiteHorse
Commentator 271
Andrea Ferich
Andrea Ferich exhibit
Andrea Ferich exhibit 2
2016 Climbers Run #2
2016 Climbers Run at Preserve
2016 Conowingo Creek
2016 Fishing Creek
2016 Pequea Creek
2016 Steinman Run
2016 Tucquan Creek
2016 UNT to Fishing Creek
Commentator 274
Mindy Roye
Commentator 278
Steve Murray
Commentator 288
Richard Stern
Commentator 289
Douglas Lorenzen
Commentator 290
Alex Lotorto
Commentator 295
Emily Kraftjack
Commentator 297
Jon Ritter
Commentator 337
Peter Butler
Commentator 340
S. R. Walker
Commentator 341
John T. Gross - letter
John T. Gross - exhibit
John T. Gross - PowerPoint
John T. Gross - Exhibit A - Brett Miller to FERC – 1-13-17
John T. Gross - Comment of Gary Erb - 10-19-16
Commentator 1296
Christopher M. Trejchel
Commentator 2544
Cathryn Maloney
Commentator 2545
Julie Brown
Commentator 2546
Sonya Vitello
Commentator 2547
John Cooper
Commentator 2549
Tim Keener – exhibit 1
Tim Keener – exhibit 2
Exhibits Received at Public Hearings with No Name Attached
ASR - FERC's Approval Based on an Incomplete Picture of Economic Impacts
Summary of PHMC Coordination
PHMC Report – 1
PHMC Report – 2
PHMC Report – 3
PHMC Report – 4
PHMC Report – 5
Unknown Testimony
Robert Farm Site Map
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission
Task Force Report
Regional Permit Coordination Office
DEP's Permit Review Process
Mariner East II
Mariner East 2X
Atlantic Sunrise
PennEast
Adelphia Gateway
Shell Falcon Ethane Pipeline
Revolution Pipeline
Leidy South
FM100
Conemaugh River Crossing Project
FM120 Insertion Project
Regional Energy Access Expansion Project
Appalachia to Market II Project
Schuylkill River HDD